This is not the front page

Building Student Engagement with Discussions

Instance Description

Whether for a resident course or online, cultivating a human-centered classroom community takes time and effort. Discussion forums can help. Content-delivery discussion forums help students interact when considering content-related questions and topics, but other kinds of discussions can help create an interactive community of learners who share and get to know each other outside of the realm of course content. Consider the following:

  • Instructor willingness to share of themselves can ease the way into building real relationships (O’Malley)
  • Instructor modeling of social presence expectations can lead to boosted performance by students (Peters)
  • Creation of social discussions free from content and assessment can promote community (Wehler)
  • Social interaction can help create a low-anxiety environment (Feole)
Image
overhead view of students sharing a round table
Photo Credit

Credit: ScreenFlow, under license agreement by Jane Sutterlin

Related Topics

See it in Practice

Image
a circle of laptops sitting on a table with arms reaching out to type
Photo Credit

Credit: "© dragonstock / stock.adobe.com” 

Discussions are an excellent way to build community and make content relevant for students, but unfortunately, they often become check-the-box activities with students logging in once, making long, essay-type posts, and then commenting on the required number of their peers’ posts the same day. This does not allow for the nuance of a true discussion with back-and-forth dialog.

To address this issue, several instructors have changed the discussion focus from the number of posts to the level of engagement. In the example below, the instructor is asking for shorter posts and more frequent interaction. The result has been more active engagement and a depth of conversation not seen in traditional discussion assignments.

Discussion Assignment

A key component of your graduate coursework is participating in online discussions with classmates. Often, online discussions become an opportunity to check a box or write a multi-page report. I would like to move our discussion beyond this to one that becomes a true conversation where we explore ideas together. In addition to being thoughtful about the discussion prompts, I would like to see you asking and answering questions, making suggestions, and sharing examples from your own life. I would like to see this begin to look like a true conversation, so while most of your posts should be a paragraph or two in length (not a page or two), some may be shorter and more casual and conversational. Remember to contribute to the learning community by being creative in your approaches to topics, being relevant in the presented viewpoints, and attempting to motivate the discussion. And remember, there is value in diverse perspectives, so it is OK to have a constructive and considerate disagreement.

Timeline

In order to mimic a real conversation, you will be expected to be online and participate in online discussions for at least four days during the discussion period. While the times of day and specific days of the week in which you do this work are flexible, you must participate actively and regularly in online discussions to be successful and fulfill your responsibilities as a member of the class learning community. I would suggest setting aside dedicated time several times a week for participation.

Lessons begin on Wednesday and the discussion will be open for ten days (even though the rest of the lesson is only scheduled for one week). Your initial post is due on Sunday. You are then required to participate in the conversation on at least three different days by or before the following Thursday.

Style

Discussion forum posts are to be conversational but remember that standard etiquette and writing rules apply -- you are expected to conduct yourself professionally, check your spelling, and write coherent sentences. When quoting from or paraphrasing articles we read in this class, it is fine to cite the author(s) parenthetically, and in-line in the text. When using outside sources, please include a bibliographical citation at the end of your post. 

Rubric

CriteriaPoints
The initial post is submitted on time.10
Follow-up posts are made on at least two different days and reflective follow-up responses are provided that extend the discussion.20
Posts are well developed and add depth to the discussion (e.g., by adding new and/or relevant ideas including links to outside content that bolsters the argument, well-reasoned critique of content being discussed, the inclusion of personal experiences and anecdotes, etc.). Posts integrate evidence from the reading, lecture, or experience in support of their argument; consistently offer insightful comments and questions that prompt additional on-topic discussion; consistently help clarify or synthesize other class members' ideas, and, if disagreeing with other class members' ideas, do so clearly and politely.20
Total50

Considerations

This type of discussion rubric can be utilized in any LMS.

Contributor(s)

Image
Discussion in Piazza
Photo Credit

Credit: Piazza, 2020

In GEOG 489: Advanced Python Programming for GIS, students work independently on programming tasks but are encouraged to use Piazza (integrated within Canvas) to hold related discussions with classmates. Here, students construct knowledge collaboratively as they assist one another, share perspectives and ideas, and answer each other’s questions. The informal and low-stakes environment (participation is optional) and the involvement of authentic, engaged instructors as collaborators check anxiety and isolation and foster a safe cognitive and social space.

Learning is a social activity, and interaction in a peer-supported environment can help make learning more durable and provide a transformational learning experience.  

Above is an excerpt from the course discussion (names withheld).

Considerations

Piazza has partnered with eSSENTIAL Accessibility to offer a free assistive technology app to members of our community who have trouble typing, moving a mouse, or reading. You can read more about our partnership and download the eSSENTIAL Accessibility app for use with Piazza.

Contributor(s)

Image
Text of reciprocal questioning assignment. See page for details.
Photo Credit

Credit: © Penn State is licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 

Reciprocal Questioning is a strategy that promotes critical thinking while increasing student engagement with one another and with the course material. Students work in small groups to discuss course material, or a portion of the course material, like a video. They discuss where they need further clarification or more information. Then a group representative shares the questions with the instructor and the instructor's Docsanswers benefit the entire class.

Assignment Details

The process works like this:

  1. Divide the class into small groups.
  2. Each group discusses the assigned lesson and brainstorms a list of questions they have about the material.
  3. After brainstorming, the group members choose their best questions and refine them.
  4. A spokesperson for each group provides the questions to the instructor.
  5. The instructor answers the questions to reinforce learning for everyone in the class.

This activity will also provide instructors with insight into how they can further develop their material to improve understanding for future students.

This activity is a great fit for face-to-face classes but can also be used in online classes with small group discussions or collaborative workspaces like Google Docs or Microsoft Whiteboard.

Contributor(s)

Image
directions for video discussion. See text below.
Photo Credit

Credit: © Penn State is licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0

Video-based asynchronous discussions are an excellent alternative, or addition to, text-based discussions. Video-based asynchronous discussions utilize an app to create a group discussion or sharing opportunity where students record short videos of themselves and respond to their peers' posts via video. Video discussions are very effective at creating social and teaching presence and increased collaboration. Asynchronous video discussions are also particularly good at decreasing a student's sense of isolation that can come from being in an online class or being a member of a minoritized group such as ESL students or women in STEM. It can also reduce the instructor’s feelings of isolation – a win-win for everyone!

This example used an app called Flip to encourage a class of multi-national students from around the globe to introduce themselves. Students were encouraged to post 1-2 minute-videos introducing themselves, their interest and experience with the course content, their expectations for the class, and some interesting facts about themselves. Students were then encouraged to respond to 2 or more of their peers via video. Student feedback was positive, with several non-Americans sharing how much they appreciated seeing and “getting to know” their classmates.

  • There are many different tools for incorporating asynchronous video discussions, including Canvas discussions utilizing the record/upload media function, Kaltura and the classroom Media Gallery, VoiceThread, and Flip.
  • You can use asynchronous video discussions for many other types of assignments including discussing course concepts, sharing observations and questions about required readings, etc.
  • Set a minimum and maximum length for each video and responses to minimize rambling and to ease time spent grading.

Considerations

Accessibility

  • Some students may initially feel uncomfortable recording themselves. Consider making the first few recordings be no or low stakes so they have time to get comfortable with the technology. It is also helpful to empathize with student discomfort and offer encouragement and rationalization for the video requirement.
  • Other students may have legal or medical reasons that prevent them from being able to record themselves. In that case, work with the student to come up with an acceptable alternative, whether that be an audio recording, text, etc.
  • If you have hearing impaired students, discuss options with the Disability Services Office.

Contributor(s)

References/Resources

  • O’Malley, Sharon (2017). Professors share ideas for building community in online courses. Retrieved from https://www.insidehighered.com/digital-learning/article/2017/07/26/ideas-building-online-community
  • Peters, D. (2014). Interface design for learners: design strategies for learning experiences. San Francisco: New Riders.
  • Wheler, M. (2018). Five ways to build community in online classrooms. Retrieved from https://www.facultyfocus.com/articles/online-education/five-ways-to-build-community-in-online-classrooms/